(Warning: Soap box post, feel free to leave and come back tomorrow if you don't like it when I do that, lol. Hugs. A)We've all heard the phrase "too stupid to live", and thunked our heads against the wall just
thinking about those dumb ass romance heroines too stupid to run from the god damned zombie chasing them down the road, or the ex-lover hiding in the closet with a knife, or what have you.
But today I'm talking about the
Too Skinny to Live, an apparently equally reviled new species of romance heroine if I'm to believe what I've seen on recent blogs, on Q & A sessions on message boards, and the one on one feedback I've received at many romance conferences throughout the years.
Many romance writers (and readers) seem to HATE skinny women--which I've gathered is anyone under a size 6. Some of the sentiments I've read lately are 'no wonder your villianesses are skinny, women who won't eat more than a leaf of lettuce are bitches, no question'. Or 'readers don't want to read about perfect people, they want someone who they can relate to'. Or 'thank goodness other people feel the same way, I want to read about healthy heroines, not stick people.'
Not to mention the numerous comments about 'sittting on the skinny people to make them shut up', or 'shut up, skinny people don't have problems', or 'look at you cute little thing, don't you just want to claw her eyes out'. (That last said at Nationals by an older romance author standing with her three friends who all laughed at me. I happened to totally idolize this woman, and after I grovelled a bit she saw my inner beauty and we bonded all girl-power like and all, but that's not the point of this post.)
I've just, well...I've had it. As a skinny person, I'm here to stick out my scrawny neck and say a few things.
1. Skinny people are not necessarily 'unhealthy'. I am naturally 120 pounds, a size 2-4, eating anything I want. Steak, chocolate for breakfast, whatever. I eat, and I eat a lot. But I also work out and try not to make those unhealthy choices too terribly often. Because I want to stay strong to keep up with my kids, not because I'm on a diet. I am not a bad role model to other women because I am thin.
And being overweight is not necessarily 'healthy'. Being obese is not good for you! It's just not. Too much weight can kill you as certainly as smoking a pack a day. I love my girlfriends, I love women, and I don't think its cool to pretend that all large women are healthy role models. Anoerexia is horrible, but so is obesity. Both ruin the lives of wonderful women. Let's promote healthy attitudes, not sizest ones in either direction. Healthy is being at a good weight for YOUR body, not anyone else's.
2. Skinny people have problems and feelings too. I am continually amazed that this fact is so hard for some people to believe. I have borderline osteoporosis, I've had cervical cancer. I've had a father die, I've had friends die, my heart has been broken by men who didn't want me. I've been told I was unattractive. I've been ridiculed and tormented by other kids when I was in school. Pain is universal. And so is discrimination. As women we already have to deal with a lot of bullshit. It makes me livid to see us attacking each other.
Just as it is cruel to make jokes to a fat person about their weight, it is also cruel to attack a thin person and tell them you're going to sit on them to make them shut up.
It is also not okay to attack me at a conference, right before my first book signing when I'm nervous as hell and just wanting to be liked. Simply because the aspect of my physical body that bothers you happens to be socially acceptable, that doesn't make it okay to make someone self-conscious and embarassed. Does it?
3. Skinny women have insecurities about their bodies too! Maybe it's their saggy post-baby tits. Or their lack of ass. Or the fact that they are so small they have to wear girl sizes and don't feel like real grown ups (not me, but I do have friends this small who rage against having to wear pink all the time). Being thin is not a get-in-free pass to Self-Confidence-Ville. It just ain't, sorry to destroy the dream.
Especially when you are the odd woman out for being thin and other women suddenly feel it's okay to make fun of you. Hearing 'shut ups skinny' or 'oh yeah, she's the skinny one' said about oneself all the time does not feel like a compliment, not even a backhanded one. It feels like a condemnation, a reason to find me unacceptable. It feels like I'm being judged for the way I look, not what I write, or what I might have to contribute to a group.
4.. Just because my ass is skinnier, that doesn't mean I should have to bend over and kiss yours.I'm a nice person. I have never made fun of anyone for the way they look, not even on the playground (because I was always too insecure myself). I don't even think negative thoughts about larger people. I honestly don't. I don't know why they're carrying extra weight around, hell I don't even know if that IS extra weight on their body. I'm not there to judge them on their weight. I'll judge them on whether or not they are assholes. If I'm an asshole to you, feel free to tear into me. But I believe it is impossible to be an asshole simply by walking around in a size 4 dress.
And so...I'm done I think. This post has been building for awhile in case you couldn't tell, lol.
I understand that overweight people have been the butt of jokes, social stigma, and just plain meanness. That is a societal problem, however, not something perpetrated by every woman who is thin. I can safely say being thin has won me very little in the way of 'freebies' of late. Instead it has inserted an uncomfortable hurdle when trying to make friends. So...let's just let the love flow man....flow...no matter how big or how small we are.
Hugs from my scrawny arms,
Anna J. Evans